Congratulations to the cast of Peter and the Starcatcher!

Matthews Playhouse had a very busy 72 hours during auditions for Peter and the Starcatcher. We would like to thank everyone who came out for auditions. Your talent, heart, and dedication to your craft is truly something to marvel at. You've made casting this production a joy while also giving us some difficult choices.

We are happy to announce the cast of Peter and the Starcatcher!

Boy/Peter: Josh Brand

Molly: Emma Brand

Black Stache: Johnny Hohenstein

Smee: Andrea King

Prentiss: Ben Allen

Ted: Alijah Wilson

Lord Aster: Andrew Pippin

Alf: Miles Thompson

Mrs. Bumbrake: Davis Hickson

Slank: Chip Bradley

Fighting Prawn/Sanchez: Neifert Enrique

Captain Scott/Teacher: Ryan Caulley 

Grempkin/Pirate: Andrew C. Moore

Hawking Clam/Mac: Zack Mahon

Director: Jill Bloede

Music Director: Sarah Baumgardner

Assistant Director: Emma Bibadeneira

Stage Manager: Jessie Hull

Assistant Stage Manager: Ellamay Ulman

Backstage Crew: Bo Mills, Naomi Davis, Will Elliott

---

Prepare to be transported on a thrilling voyage with Peter & the Starcatcher, a Tony Award-winning play that reimagines the timeless tale of how a downtrodden orphan transforms into the iconic Peter Pan. Set aboard the ship The Neverland, this high-seas adventure introduces us to three spirited orphan boys. Their journey takes an unexpected turn when they cross paths with Molly Aster, a clever and quick-witted girl, who happens to be the daughter of an English lord and serves as a minister to the queen. 

A Play by Rick Elice

Music by Wayne Barker

July 11-27, 2025

A Play with Music in 2 Acts

Approximate Run Time is 2.5 hours 

Recommended for ages 8 and up

TICKETS ON SALE NOW!